Trying Online Dating after the Death of a Spouse

Posted by:

A reader recently contacted me about determining the “right” time to date again after her husband had died. Specifically, she was looking to know if she should give it a try or if that would be a mistake. Here is the basic idea from her email:

My husband passed away some time ago and I’m starting to consider dating again but I’m not sure if online dating would right for me. I’m not sure if I’m ready. Can I sign up for one month to see if it is what I’m looking for? I’m not sure how I’ll feel when I meet new people and I want to be fair to them. I’m confused about what I want at this point and I wouldn’t want to hurt anyone.

I’ve never personally experienced losing a spouse so my advice here may be lacking, but I’ll give my opinion. I have talked with many people about the struggle of deciding when to date for different reasons so hopefully some of that experience will be helpful.

So When is the Right Time to Date Again?
To me, when you lose a spouse, it’s a personal issue in regards to when to start dating again. No one can tell you when it is the right or wrong time to date. There is no universal calendar that says, “On this date, it’s time to start dating again”. For some people, they may find they desire a relationship in a relatively short time while others may never date again…and in both cases that might be the right thing to do.

I think it comes down to determining where you are in the grieving process and determining if you’re ready to try. For example, one sign that you may be ready to date is if you are asking yourself questions like, “Is it okay for me to date right now? Have I waited long enough? I think I want to date, but will I make a fool of myself if I do?” Are you arguing with yourself over dating again? That suggests a desire to find a relationship again. This desire doesn’t mean you’re ready for a new relationship, but it does suggest that you are headed in that direction.

Perhaps a better place to start isn’t to try to determine if you’re ready to start dating in general, but instead ask yourself if you could see yourself going on one date. Is that something you could handle? Does it interest you? Or are you afraid you would become an emotional wreck?

If you have doubts and concerns with the idea of one date, I would wait. Even just being horribly confused could be a sign to wait. But perhaps answering those questions make you feel that you are ready for one date. That is great but before signing up for a dating service, consider the risks of dating too soon.

The Risks of Dating Too Soon
You may feel you are ready to date again but I would encourage some caution and serious thought before jumping in. I’m sure there are many risks to dating too quickly after the death of a husband or wife but here are two big ones that come to my mind:

  1. If you’re not ready, you may get emotional on your first dates and that could be embarrassing. As was my reader’s concern, this could be seen as wasting the other person’s time. But I see another big drawback to this: if you have a bad first experience, it could cause you to wait far too long to try again or might even convince you that you should never try again. You could create a situation where it takes much longer for you to find a new relationship once you are ready.
  2. If you’re not ready, you may make poor emotional decisions. You may feel strongly enough that you allow yourself to get into a situation where you are taken advantage of. Or, on the other end of the spectrum, you may end up rejecting men/women because you talk yourself out of pursing a new relationship (as the idea may become very frightening)

So what’s the solution? How do you know if you’re moving too soon? Unfortunately, I don’t think I can answer that question in an article like this: I don’t know the details of your personal situation nor can I understand fully the pain you have gone through. My advice (which, by its nature, is rather generic) can only take you so far.

With that in mind, I’d really recommend opening up to a close friend. Someone who knows you. Someone who has been with you as you’ve gone through the pain of losing your wife or husband. This could even come in the form of a pastor or therapist.

My thought is this: sometimes when we’ve experienced a traumatic event, it’s difficult for us to judge our own decision making. Bringing in a close friend that can help us see the wisdom (or error) in moving forward is a huge help. I hope an article like this one is helpful “generally”, but when we get to the specifics of your situation, I feel you need someone who can give more personal advice.

Benefits of Online Dating
If you decide it is time to move forward, I do believe there are benefits to dating online as a way to re-enter the dating world. I would see some of those benefits including:

  • You can try for short periods to see how you do. If you try it for two days and decide you aren’t ready, you can hide your profile then come back 3 months later and pick up where you left off.
  • There is a lot of control in who you meet and how quickly you meet.
  • It can provide an opportunity to find people who have gone through a similar situation.
  • People online know you want to date. Those around you may not pursue a relationship with you for fear that you’re not ready (but at the same time you don’t feel comfortable announcing to the world that you’re looking to date again)
  • If it has been a long time since you have dated, there are services that can walk you step-by-step through the process (with eHarmony being the one that comes quickest to my mind)

That said, I don’t think online dating has to be a part of finding a new relationship. I just see benefits to using one.

Having highlighted some benefits, I would urge caution when using online dating because it can present many opportunities very rapidly…with some of those opportunities being less good than others. I would again suggest that you keep a friend involved as you begin to date. Add a voice of reason to the decisions you are making. Maybe even give them the power to veto dates or to tell you it’s time to take a break. A close friend who can help in this process is priceless.

Be Aware of Auto-Renewals
My reader’s idea of just trying online dating for a month is a reasonable one. It might even be fine if you had no first dates that first month (not saying you should avoid meeting people, I’m just saying if it didn’t happen right away that might be okay).

However, be aware that all major dating services that I’m aware of auto-renew your account. If you sign up for 1 month, as soon as that month is up they will immediately charge you again and give you another month of time. You actually have to cancel your subscription to stop them from charging you again. So if you do sign up for a month, be sure to cancel your account before a month is up (especially if you discover that online dating isn’t something you’re ready for).


Again, I realize there is a lot I can’t speak to on this topic but I do hope that this article was helpful. If there are any readers who have gone through this process who would like to leave suggestions in the comments, it would be greatly appreciated.

 

7

About the Author:

Brad initially struggled with online dating but over time became quite successful using it. He met his wife using online dating and has been giving advice and helping people improve their results since 2007. He has written a Free Online Dating Guide to help others find success with online dating. You can learn more about his personal experience using online dating and running this website here.

Comments

  1. Jan  April 8, 2012

    I am a widow and I feel that there are men out there who are potentially scamming widows. Quite a few men who have contacted me are much younger than I am and they say that they are looking for women as much as 40 years older than they are. It seems really strange and abnormal that a man of, say 40 years old would be looking for a woman who is 80, as stated in their profile. Has this happened to any other widows out there? I ignore all those contacts. But I also wonder if men generally have a negative view of dating a widow? Why?

    • jolene  September 23, 2013

      I put Widow as my status last time I tried online dating, and felt that I was potentially being targetted for it.

      So this time I put Single and found it made no difference – I still had weirdos and men much younger than me getting in touch!

      That said, I personally would prefer to tell someone if and when I think we might meet rather than have it there up front for them all to see.

  2. Lauren  May 16, 2012

    My husband passed away just over 2 months before I joined Match.com. It may sound early for some people but my husband had a long illness, died just after he turned 40, we had a horrible marriage and were on the verge of divorce prior to his diagnosis of ALS (Lou Gehrig’s Disease) and we had no children. I’m 36 years old and I spent the last 2 years taking care of him and dying a little bit on the inside myself. Im a social person and I’m really looking forward to meeting new people. I’m concerned that if I don’t get back on the horse I might be viewed as “too old” to have children with. I’m very concerned but I’m also worried that I’m going to be seen as being out there too soon. My husband spent quite a bit of time on Match himself during the course of our marriage but how do you say that to someone who might be asking about what happened to your husband? I’ve certainly had no one trying to take advantage of me because I’m a widow.

  3. Brad  May 17, 2012

    Lauren – I think in the early stages of dating the details of you situation aren’t something you would need to share. I think it would be fine for you to let anyone who asks know that your husband passed away but that you’d rather not talk about the details until you get to know each other better. Then, if you think you’ve found a man you’d like to date more seriously, just be honest with him like you were here. On paper, dating 2 months after the death of a spouse does sound early but I think once someone knows you better and you explain the situation, they should be understanding.

  4. Pam  September 17, 2013

    My husband of 30 years passed away from cancer 1-1/2 years ago at the age of 56. We had a very good marriage and were happy. With my grown children’s blessings, I put a profile on POF six months ago. I was very cautious, not my real name, not my real hometown, etc. I communicated via emails with several men I was matched with or saw my profile. I met one guy, after many emails and then phone calls, at a mall. No chemistry. I then met another guy that I found out through emails golfed with my cousin’s husband. I was less cautious this time since we had mutual acquaintances. In a few days we will have the four month anniversary of our first date and we are falling in love for sure. It is very, very nice to be with someone that cares about me again. My friends and family also love him. I feel very lucky.

  5. Hermina  January 31, 2017

    I think your advice is very sound, Brad. Considering you haven’t been through this personally, your answers are wise and spot on. I’m not quite at the stage of “joining up” yet (this after the seventh anniversary of my husband’s death) but have started to dip my toe into the e-dating waters. One piece of advice I got from a (female) friend with whom I discussed this was: low-ball your income, if you reveal it at all – which might head off fortune hunters at the pass.

  6. Nigel  April 23, 2018

    I started dating quite early after the death of my wife and it had positives and negatives. I was definitely not ready for a relationship but the getting out and meeting people (especially people who had similar experiences) was very helpful. One thing to watch is the message it sends any children you might have. I was aware of this and tried to mitigate it but not wholly successfully. It took me a whole year before I managed to have a longish relationship and ironically that started offline!

    I would say do it when you feel you want to start. It did me a lot of good. However be aware you are emotionally more vulnerable than most and if there are significant other people in your life they need to understand your motives so that they see you are not being disrespectful to your dead spouse.